NCP leader Nawab Malik has approached the Bombay High Court seeking bail in a money laundering case, citing kidney failure as the reason. Malik's parents and brother have also died of the same ailment. His counsel submitted that he had been undergoing treatment for various ailments since his arrest in February last year and had suffered kidney failure. The bench sought the medical report of JJ Hospital doctors to understand the extent of Malik?s ailment.
Mumbai: Nationalist Congress Party leader Nawab Malik on Tuesday told the Bombay high court that his parents and brother have died of kidney failures, and since he too is suffering from a failed kidney, he should be granted bail in the money laundering case. Malik approached the HC after the special court rejected his bail application in November last year.
HT Image
Malik’s counsel, senior advocate Amit Desai, on Tuesday, submitted that the 64-year-old was admitted to a hospital after his arrest in February last year. Desai submitted that Malik had been undergoing treatment for various ailments since then and had suffered kidney failure.
“Medical reports show that the other kidney is functioning at 60% and the report of the panel of doctors from JJ Hospital also suggested continuous monitoring,” Desai said, adding that the panel from the hospital have contrasting views. The senior doctor said that Malik required constant monitoring, while one of the panellists thought that the problem could be taken care of through outpatient-department visits.
Before Desai commenced his submissions, the single-judge bench of justice Anuja Prabhudessai sought clarity on whether Malik was seeking bail under the provisions of PMLA on medical grounds or on merit. The bench said that if it was on medical grounds, it would be only an interim bail.
Desai responded saying that he was willing to argue on both medical grounds as well as on merit but would restrict himself to arguing on medical grounds as of now, he would argue on merits later. The court accepted the same and sought the medical report of the JJ Hospital doctors to understand the extent of the seriousness of Malik’s ailment.
Desai told the bench that the medical reports would be made available in the course of the hearing. He added that Malik’s kidney problem was hereditary, and his parents had succumbed to it at the age of 70 years and his brother died at the age of 52 years, hence he should be granted bail. Desai also submitted that the Enforcement Directorate (ED) did not challenge Malik’s hospitalisation order nor had it applied for shifting Malik back to jail from the hospital. He concluded this showed that Malik was having a severe problem.
After hearing Desai for a while, the bench said it would continue the hearing on Wednesday