close_game
close_game

Weather Bee | Why is the global temperature high despite La Nina's arrival?

Jan 17, 2025 08:17 PM IST

Since the La Nina is expected to be weak and short-lived, its influence may be even more insignificant than in recent years.

La Nina, a cyclical cooling of the equatorial Pacific Ocean, had arrived by the second week of December. A La Nina is expected to cool down global temperatures. Yet, not only was December 2024 ranked the second warmest December month in recorded history, but warming relative to the pre-industrial average was more than 1.5°C in the month in most datasets. Why is the La Nina not cooling down global temperature? One reason for this is that there is a lag from the onset of Nina to a cooling in global temperatures. The second reason is that the La Nina cannot affect the long-term warming that anthropogenic emissions are causing. Here is how.

Snow covers a rock as drifting broken sea ice, floats on the surface, off the extreme western point of Replot Island, in Kvarken archipelago, near Bjorkoby, in the northern part of the Baltic Sea on January 15, 2025. Due to a mild winter and temperatures above zero degrees centigrade, the open sea has not frozen. (Photo by Olivier MORIN / AFP)(AFP) PREMIUM
Snow covers a rock as drifting broken sea ice, floats on the surface, off the extreme western point of Replot Island, in Kvarken archipelago, near Bjorkoby, in the northern part of the Baltic Sea on January 15, 2025. Due to a mild winter and temperatures above zero degrees centigrade, the open sea has not frozen. (Photo by Olivier MORIN / AFP)(AFP)

The onset of La Nina (or its opposite phenomena, the El Nino) is usually tracked using sea surface temperature (SST) deviations in the Nino3.4 region (5N-5S, 170W-120W). When SSTs cooldown by at least 0.5°C consistently compared to a 30-year average updated every five years, a La Nina is declared. With hindsight (this trend has held beyond the second week of December) and forecasts, one can say that La Nina arrived by the second week of December.

Despite the arrival of La Nina, five out of six global temperature datasets showed that December last year was warmer than the pre-industrial average by more than the pre-industrial average. It was also the second warmest December month, just behind December 2023. In fact, daily ERA5 data from the Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S) shows that global temperatures have not cooled down so far in January either.

Each of the first 13 days of the month (the period for which this data is available) was at least 1.64°C warmer than the pre-industrial average. Even allowing for the fact that ERA5 usually shows a higher level of warming than other datasets, this is far too warm (2025 was the first year when the annual average crossed 1.5°C warming in multiple datasets) for comfort. For example, each day from January 3 to January 11 was the warmest this year, and other days were the second warmest this year. If these trends continue, January 2025 will at least end up as the second warmest January on record, a fact that most datasets are likely to agree on.

Chart 1(Abhishek Jha)
Chart 1(Abhishek Jha)

Why is La Nina not cooling down global temperatures? As explained above, there is a lag between the onset of La Nina (or El Nino) and its impact on global temperatures. How long is this lag? Around three months if previous trends hold. To find this expected duration, HT removed the long-term trend from global temperatures (where factors other than cyclical ones, such as El Nino and La Nina) and SSTs in the Nino 3.4 region and calculated the correlation between them. This shows that, for the 1950-2024 period, the correlation is strongest at a 3-month lag, although the strength of the correlation at a 2-month or 4-month lag is not drastically different. Nonetheless, that the correlation is stronger at a lag suggests that we cannot expect air temperatures (or what is commonly known simply as temperature) to cool down at the same time as the equatorial Pacific.

To be sure, even in a few months, the cooling is unlikely to be anything more than cyclical. In other words, we might expect temperatures cooler than what they were when an El Nino was underway (such as last year), but not drastically cooler. This can be seen in the super-imposed chart of SST deviations in the Nino3.4 region and global temperatures. In the long-term, global temperatures during La Nina are now warmer than what they were during La Nina events in the past.

The trends described above mean that the impact of La Nina and El Nino events is relatively insignificant compared to the long-term warming that greenhouse gas emissions have caused. Therefore, the relief from La Nina is likely to be only relative to the past year of El Nino. In fact, since the La Nina is expected to be weak and short-lived, its influence may be even more insignificant than in recent years. Therefore, it is not surprising that the UK Met Department has forecast that 2025 will likely be one of the three warmest years on record.

Abhishek Jha, HT’s senior data journalist, analyses one big weather trend in the context of the ongoing climate crisis every week, using weather data from ground and satellite observations spanning decades.

rec-icon Recommended Topics
Share this article
See More

For evolved readers seeking more than just news

Subscribe now to unlock this article and access exclusive content to stay ahead
E-paper | Expert Analysis & Opinion | Geopolitics | Sports | Games
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
SHARE
Story Saved
Live Score
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, February 12, 2025
Start 14 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Follow Us On