Electric blankets vs traditional quilts: Which keeps you toasty warm during the chilly winter months?

Confused about choosing between electric blankets and traditional quilts? Read on to understand which is better and which to avoid during winter.

It’s not as thrilling as a superhero showdown, but the debate between electric blankets and traditional quilts can stir up just as much passion, especially when winter chills are at their peak. Whether you're curling up on the couch or preparing for a restful night’s sleep, choosing the right way to stay warm is more important than ever.

Electric blankets or traditional quilts which are your perfect winter companion.

As winter temperatures drop, many of us turn to these common comforts, but what’s truly the best option for battling the cold? Electric blankets and traditional quilts both have their loyal followers, each offering different advantages in terms of warmth, comfort, cost, and safety. So, in this article, we’ll compare these two winter essentials across various factors to help you decide which is the better choice for your winter needs.

Overview of electric blankets and how they work

An electric blanket is a great way to stay warm without cranking up the heating. It heats up quickly, helps you relax, and gives you the flexibility to adjust the temperature. Let’s have a closer look at how they work and the different types available.

What are electric blankets?

Electric blankets, sometimes called bed warmers, are a convenient way to stay warm without increasing the thermostat. These blankets have an electric heater woven inside, which helps spread the heat evenly across their surface. Typically, they rest on top of your sheets, but some versions are designed to be placed underneath the bottom sheet. Just make sure you know which type you have and follow the manufacturer’s guidelines. It’s important not to put blankets meant for the top underneath, as this could be risky.

The primary purpose of an electric blanket is to warm its surface; either to preheat the bed before you slip into it, to maintain warmth while you're resting, or to target heat to a specific area of the body. However, it’s essential to ensure the skin is always covered by another layer of fabric, as direct contact with the heated surface can lead to burns.

How does an electric blanket work?

An electric blanket works by simply plugging into your mains electricity. Inside the blanket, you'll find a thermostat that helps regulate the temperature, ensuring you stay comfortable throughout the night. As the electricity flows through the wires evenly spread across the blanket, it’s converted into heat.

The newer versions of electric blankets use fibreglass cables, which are thinner, more flexible, and safer than older models. These cables emit infrared heat, making them more energy-efficient and giving you a better, more comfortable experience overall. It’s this combination of improved technology and thoughtful design that makes modern electric blankets a comfortable, reliable option to keep you warm.

Types of electric blankets and their best uses

Electric blankets come in two main types: under blankets and over blankets. Here's a breakdown of each, followed by some real-world use cases to help you decide which one fits your needs.

1. Under electric blankets

These are designed to be placed directly on your mattress, usually secured with elastic straps or cords. The heat is spread evenly across the surface, warming the bed from underneath. They are perfect for preheating your bed before sleep or providing consistent warmth while you're lying in it. Just remember to place a sheet over it to protect your skin from direct heat.

Use case: If you struggle with getting into a cold bed during winter, an under blanket is ideal. It warms your entire mattress, creating a cosy environment, perfect for those who enjoy the comforting feel of warmth beneath them as they sleep.

Consider these under electric blankets:

• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...

2. Over electric blankets

Unlike under blankets, over blankets sit on top of your bed, providing warmth directly to your body. These blankets can be used on their own or placed inside a duvet for extra heat. Over blankets are great for those who want to target specific body areas like your feet or shoulders.

Use case: Over blankets are great for those who feel colder in certain areas of their body, like their feet, or who want quick, adjustable warmth while lounging. They're also a good option for a cosy movie night on the couch, offering heat on demand without having to heat the whole bed.

Consider these over electric blankets:

• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...

Now that you've got the idea of electric blankets, it's time to understand traditional quilts, which offer a classic, natural warmth that's both comforting and timeless.

Overview of traditional quilts and their types

Traditional blankets are timeless essentials that offer comfort and warmth in various forms. Whether you're looking for something warm for the winter or breathable for the warmer months, traditional blankets come in many types, each with its unique benefits.

1. Wool blankets are perfect for colder climates, known for their warmth, durability, and natural resistance to flames and moisture.

Consider these woollen blankets:

• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...

2. Cotton blankets are light, breathable, and ideal for warmer temperatures, available in different weaves like thermal or waffle for added texture and comfort.

Consider these cotton blankets:

• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...

3. Fleece blankets are soft, affordable, and easy to care for, providing a comfy, lightweight option that’s perfect for everyday use.

Consider these fleece blankets:

• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...
• Loading Suggestions...

Each option offers its own distinct advantages, catering to varying tastes and needs, making the choice clear and informed.

Electric blankets vs traditional quilts

Aspect	Electric Blankets	Traditional Quilts
Heating	Provides adjustable heat for personalised comfort.	No heating, relies on insulation and layering.
Comfort	Offers warmth with soft, flexible fibreglass cables.	Soft and comfy but dependent on the material (cotton, wool).
Energy efficiency	More energy-efficient, especially newer models with infrared heating.	No electricity needed, purely dependent on insulation.
Safety features	Includes automatic shut-off timers, overheat protection, and thermostats.	No risk of overheating or electrical hazards.
Maintenance	Requires care to prevent damage to electrical components, easy to wash with removable cords.	Low maintenance, washable in many cases depending on the fabric.
Durability	Can last for several years with proper care, but wires may degrade over time.	Highly durable, especially wool or cotton quilts that improve with age.
Size and fit	Available in various sizes, designed to fit standard bed sizes.	Comes in a variety of sizes (twin, queen, king) but no electrical components.
Cost	Higher upfront cost due to electrical components, but affordable in the long run.	Affordable initial cost, but no ongoing energy costs.
Use cases	Best for preheating the bed or providing heat during sleep in colder months.	Ideal for layering with other blankets, comfort, and warmth without electricity.
Convenience	Easy to adjust the temperature and get instant warmth.	Requires layering for warmth and may take longer to heat up.
Environmental impact	Uses electricity, which can contribute to carbon emissions (though newer models may be more eco-friendly).	No electricity required, making them more sustainable overall.
Health benefits	Provides soothing heat therapy for muscle pain and arthritis relief.	Offers natural, non-electric warmth without the risk of overheating.

6 key things to keep in mind before buying your electric blanket

When winter hits and you need that extra warmth, an electric blanket can be a game-changer. But before you jump in, here are a few things to keep in mind:

1. Comfortable fabrics

Most electric blankets are made from soft fabrics like polyester or fleece. Don’t worry, polyester isn’t as bad as it sounds! It's plush, comfy, and perfect for keeping you warm. Avoid cotton if you can, as it’s flammable and not ideal for this purpose.

2. Heat settings matter

Look for blankets with adjustable heat settings. Some even let you control each side separately, which is great if you and your partner prefer different temperatures.

3. Cord length is key

Make sure the cord is long enough to reach your bed easily. You don’t want to deal with the hassle of finding a nearby plug.

4. Safety first

Always use the blanket flat; never fold or bunch it up. Also, nothing should be placed on top of it. This can trap heat and damage the wires. For added reassurance, choose one with an auto-shut-off feature, so you can rest easy knowing it’s safe even if you forget to turn it off.

5. Washing made easy

Many electric blankets are machine washable, which makes cleaning so much easier. Just follow the instructions and remember to detach all cords and remotes before washing.

6. Know when it’s time to replace

A well-maintained electric blanket can last up to 10 years. But if you notice uneven heating or any discolouration, it’s time to get a new one.

So, which one to choose?

Choosing between an electric blanket and a traditional quilt really comes down to personal preference. If you're after quick warmth, easy temperature control, and extra comfort during those chilly nights, an electric blanket emerges as the winner. It’s a lifesaver in cold weather. But if you’re someone who loves natural, breathable fabrics and the cosiness that comes with the simple, classic feel of a quilt, then a traditional blanket takes the crown. Ultimately, it’s about comfort, convenience, and what fits your lifestyle.

Similar stories for you

Best room heater brands in India: Top 10 heating solutions

Top room heaters: 10 premium choices to match your taste

Bajaj room heaters: Choose from our top 10 picks that guarantee warmth this winter

Small room heater for bedroom: Top 9 models under ₹1500

FAQs about electric blankets vs traditional quilts:

• Are electric blankets safe to use every night?

  Yes, electric blankets are safe when used according to the manufacturer’s instructions and with an automatic shut-off feature.

• Can electric blankets be washed?

  Yes, many electric blankets are machine washable, but always check the care instructions before washing.

• Do traditional quilts provide the same warmth as electric blankets?

  Traditional quilts offer warmth but lack the adjustable heat control and instant warmth that electric blankets provide.

• Which is better for people with sensitive skin, electric blankets or traditional quilts?

  Traditional quilts are better for sensitive skin as they are made from natural fabrics and don’t involve electrical components.

• Can an electric blanket replace a traditional quilt in colder climates?

  Yes, electric blankets are more effective in colder climates, providing customizable warmth, but a traditional quilt can still offer comfort in milder conditions.

Disclaimer: At Hindustan Times, we help you stay up-to-date with the latest trends and products. Hindustan Times has an affiliate partnership, so we may get a part of the revenue when you make a purchase. We shall not be liable for any claim under applicable laws, including but not limited to the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, with respect to the products. The products listed in this article are in no particular order of priority.